8 Independent Toy Stores on Long Island

Here at the Mamas Network, we recommend you buy as local as possible. One great way to do that is to buy from local independent toy stores. We chatted with Josh Muskin, a local area toy rep recently who told us, “These businesses are there for their community all year round — so while sales at the big box stores may be tempting, don’t forget the amazing customer service you’ll get at a local shop. Ask your local shopkeeper for toy recommendations – they know their products and will always know the perfect gift for a child!”

1. Fun Stuff Toys in Seaford

This store has great in-store toy demos. Owner Mike Timko will demonstrate a toy in the middle of the store to show a parent how awesome it is.  They have a tremendous variety, great staff, and convenient parking.

Where: 3639 Merrick Road Seaford, NY 11783
Info: Website


2. Funky Monkey in Greenvale

The most beautiful toy store in Long island. Be on the lookout and take advantage of their “Funky Deals”  They offer an impressive book section and the most amazing gift wrapping (thick paper, high quality).

Where: 360 Wheatley Plaza Greenvale, NY 11548
Info: (516) 484 -0966  Funky Monkey in Greenvale


3. Matty’s Toy Stop

Mattys has  7 locations on Long Island, the main one being in Hewlett. This family- run business is the best combination of mass and specialty toys. If you see it on TV, it’s in these stores — if it’s a specialty board game, it’s in these stores.

Where: 1350 Peninsula Blvd Hewlett, NY 11557
(516) 295-2555  Matty’s Toy Stop


4. Lainie’s Way in Port Jefferson Village

See our recent review here.

Where: 109 Main Street Port Jefferson Village, NY
Info: (631) 474-5558, or info@lainiesway.com


5. Fantastic Kids in Great Neck

Great Neck’s local beautiful toy store that also has a sister in Manhattan.

Where: 50 Middle Neck Rd Great Neck, NY 11021
Contact Info: (516) 504-1158


6. Stevenson’s Toys and Games in Southampton

A Southampton staple, you can get lost in this store! From floor to ceiling, the location has been a toy store for 100 years and they are fully stocked for any gif giving need.

Where: 68 Jobs Lane Southampton, NY 11968
Contact Info: Website – (631) 283-2111


7. Second Star to the Right in Bridgehampton

Owner Marianne Kearns moved into the Bridgehampton Commons Shopping Center, gutted and redid her store and it’s GORGEOUS! There’s a Terrific staff and is part of the Good Toy Group,  which sets a standard for quality and product choice.

Where: 2044 Montauk Hwy #11 Bridgehampton, NY  11932
Info: Website – Website (631) 537-6111


8. Dolphin Bookstore in Port Washington

This Port Washington institution has terrific windows! The store is filled with a killer selection of books, cards and toys. It’s woman owned and operated and a cafe may open up inside of it soon.

Where: 299 Main Street  Port Washington, NY 11050
Contact Info: Website (516) 767-2650


Share This Post


4 thoughts on “8 Independent Toy Stores on Long Island

  1. Lara Murphy

    I live one town away from Matty’s in Rockville Center….. I always try to buy from local independently owned shops….. Unfortunately, the workers are very rude and the prices are extremely high!!! Fun Stuff Toys in Seaford is great!!!!!

  2. Kim Schechter

    You missed the BEST one in Plainview called MJ Beanz–the owners are fantastic with the latest in toys–you can call, tell them what you are looking for, in the price range and then they will have it wrapped and for you to pick up. Wrapping is free!!!!!

  3. Dan

    I love shopping at speciality shops. They have a passion that’s not found at Toys R Us and online retailers such as Amazon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>